Private Internet Access vs Surfshark
Private Internet Access and Surfshark are both reputable no-log VPNs, but they differ in pricing structure and feature emphasis. PIA focuses on affordability and customization, while Surfshark prioritizes simultaneous connections and modern infrastructure.
Private Internet Access (PIA)
A privacy-focused VPN owned by Kape Technologies with over 35,000 servers across 84+ countries. Known for affordable pricing, strong encryption, and extensive customization options for advanced users.
Monthly Price
Starts $11.99; annual ~$20-24/year (promotional)
Server Count
35,000+ across 84+ countries
Simultaneous Connections
10 devices
Logging Policy
No-logs verified by audits
Pros
- Lowest annual pricing among major VPNs, often under $2/month
- Highly configurable with custom DNS, proxy settings, and MACE ad-blocker
- Proven no-log policy independently audited multiple times
Cons
- Slower performance than competitors in recent speed benchmarks
- Allows only 10 simultaneous connections, limiting multi-device use
- Older interface design compared to modern VPN apps
Surfshark
A modern VPN with unlimited simultaneous connections and a focus on user experience. Features advanced security tools like CleanWeb and operates a fast, globally distributed network of 3,200+ servers.
Monthly Price
Starts $14.99; annual ~$40-48/year
Server Count
3,200+ across 100+ countries
Simultaneous Connections
Unlimited
Logging Policy
No-logs independently verified
Pros
- Unlimited simultaneous connections across all devices and family members
- Faster average speeds and better performance in speed tests
- Modern, intuitive interface with feature-rich apps across all platforms
Cons
- More expensive than PIA: typically $3-4/month on annual plans
- Smaller server network (3,200+ vs PIA's 35,000+)
- Owned by Surfshark B.V., a smaller company with less established track record
Surfshark wins
Surfshark's unlimited connections, faster speeds, and superior user experience outweigh PIA's cost advantage for most users, especially families and those requiring multi-device access.
Private Internet Access (PIA)
Best for budget-conscious solo users, privacy purists, and advanced users who value customization and don't mind slower speeds.
Surfshark
Best for families, multi-device households, streaming users, and those prioritizing ease of use and modern performance.
Performance & Speed Comparison
Download Speeds
Surfshark consistently delivers faster speeds in third-party benchmarks; PIA trades speed for price optimization.
Connection Stability
Both are reliable, but Surfshark's modern infrastructure shows marginally fewer disconnects in user reports.
Encryption Strength
Both offer military-grade AES-256 encryption; no meaningful difference in security implementation.
Server Coverage
PIA's 35,000+ servers far exceed Surfshark's 3,200+, offering more geographic redundancy and load distribution.
Multi-Device Support
Surfshark allows unlimited simultaneous connections; PIA caps at 10, making Surfshark vastly superior for families.
Ease of Use
Surfshark's modern UI and intuitive settings appeal to casual users; PIA's advanced options suit power users but intimidate beginners.
Pricing & Feature Breakdown
| Aspect | Private Internet Access (PIA) | Surfshark |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Price (Promotional) | $20–24/year (~$1.67–2/mo) | $40–48/year (~$3.33–4/mo) |
| Simultaneous Connections | 10 devices | Unlimited |
| Server Network Size | 35,000+ servers | 3,200+ servers |
| Ad/Malware Blocker | MACE (included) | CleanWeb (included) |
| No-Log Verification | Multiple independent audits | Independent audit completed |
Use Case & Value Proposition
PIA is the budget champion: choose it if you're price-conscious, need advanced customization, or primarily use one or two devices. Surfshark suits families, heavy multi-device users, and those prioritizing modern performance and ease of setup. For streaming and torrenting, Surfshark's speed edge matters; for privacy-first users who tolerate older interfaces, PIA's aggressive pricing wins.
When to choose each
Choose Private Internet Access (PIA) if…
Best for budget-conscious solo users, privacy purists, and advanced users who value customization and don't mind slower speeds.
Choose Surfshark if…
Best for families, multi-device households, streaming users, and those prioritizing ease of use and modern performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Surfshark is the clear winner with unlimited simultaneous connections, allowing every family member to connect at once. PIA's 10-device limit becomes a bottleneck in households with smartphones, tablets, laptops, and smart TVs.
PIA costs roughly $1.67–2/month annually, while Surfshark averages $3.33–4/month—PIA is significantly cheaper, but Surfshark's unlimited connections and faster speeds justify the premium for many users.
Yes, both maintain verified no-log policies backed by independent audits and use strong AES-256 encryption. Security is virtually identical; the choice depends on features, speed, and pricing preferences rather than safety concerns.
Sources & references
Suggested sources to verify product details, pricing, reviews, and specifications.
- OfficialSurfshark Official Features & Pricing
Surfshark subscription tiers, unlimited connections, and server network details
- ReferencePrivate Internet Access VPN Review (2026)
Private Internet Access (PIA) is probably the most popular VPN on the market today. Despite being one of the cheapest VP
- ReferencePrivate Internet Access Review 2026: Is PIA VPN Good?
How would you rate Private Internet Access's customer service? ... Amazing customer service Great customer service